NRSP logo and Climate NOT Kyoto tag
 

 

NRSP Allied Scientist Dr. Richard Courtney analyzes the following excerpt from the CBC Web piece “Wording climate change policy no easy task

“Stone says the conclusions the [IPCC] delegates are trying to sum up are very clear. Climate change is unequivocal. Temperature changes are very likely due to human influence, we are seeing the impacts already, they will get greater, and we have the tools to act. “The scientific question about is this real or not has been settled. And it is legitimately a threat. It’s a threat to our civilizations, our humanity, our ecosystems and the like, and only a fool walks away from a threat.””

By Dr. Courtney:

Yes, climate change is unequivocal. Climate has always changed everywhere and it always will: this has been known since the Bronze Age when - according to the Bible (ref. Genesis 41: 34-36) - it was pointed out to Pharaoh by Joseph.

There is no evidence to support the assertion that "Temperature changes are very likely due to human influence". Indeed, the assertion is not consistent with the fact that global temperature has not again reached the high it did in the El Nino year of 1998 despite a 4% increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration since then.

And the assertions that “we are seeing the impacts already, they will get greater, and we have the tools to act” are untrue.

1. No unprecedented climate changes have been seen recently and, therefore, there is no evidence of any kind that we are seeing impacts of AGW.

2. It is not possible to know whether or not the impacts ”will get greater” when those impacts are not known to exist.

3. There are no known “tools” that could stop climate change. Climate has always changed everywhere and it always will.

And the remainder of the quotation is a construction of more untruths built on the foundation of the three falsehoods refuted in points 1 to 3 above.


back to NRSP News

 

 
   Copyright 2006, NRSP NRSP background | the NRSP strategy | get involved !  | NRSP people | contact info | home